When it comes to buying a hydrofoil, the investment is certainly not negligible and there are many factors to evaluate.
A more frequent question is what is the difference between aluminum foils and carbon foils, in addition to the price of course, which is clearly evident to anyone. In this post we will try to clarify the main differences between the two materials.
The aluminum kitefoil:
An aluminum hydrofoil promotes ease of use and stability at the expense of speed and high performance, but its biggest and undeniable advantage is undoubtedly the price.
Aluminum is heavier than carbon, but the additional weight is not necessarily a defect. The weight in fact increases stability and makes the foil particularly suitable for beginners or free-riders who prefer the "user-friendly" description rather than "high performance".
A disadvantage of aluminum construction is the regular maintenance required to prevent parts from welding together or corroding. After each use, an aluminum foil must be disassembled, washed with fresh water and lubricated with the special protection. Forgetting it even once could have irreversible consequences ... keep this in mind even when you buy your used foil.
Advantages of aluminum for kitefoil:
Significantly lower cost
More impact resistant than carbon
Greater stability due to greater weight
Disadvantages of aluminum for kitefoil:
Greater heaviness
Shafts can bend under heavy stresses
Greater maintenance required to prevent corrosion
Less rigidity and smoothness of carbon
The carbon kitefoil:
Carbon is more rigid and resistant than aluminum, which makes it more suitable for those looking for maximum performance, for jumping or for very heavy riders who could bend an aluminum shaft. On the other hand, carbon is extremely susceptible to impacts and can break completely even with a small impact with a rock.
Carbon also gives the foil greater smoothness and efficiency. A carbon foil is generally more agile and responsive. The speed achievable with a carbon foil is higher, agility is greater and even upwind is better.
On the other hand, carbon foils are less simple for a beginner to tame, precisely because of their great sensitivity.
Carbon benefits for kitefoil:
Lightness
Greater rigidity better for situations of high speed, jump and high torque
More "slip" than aluminum
Less "cavitation at high speeds"
Less maintenance
Disadvantages of carbon for kitefoil:
Higher cost Greater fragility - dislikes rocks
In conclusion, is a carbon or aluminum kitefoil better?
If you are an expert rider looking for maximum performance, there is no need for us to tell you that your hydrofoil should be carbon.
On the other hand, if you are a beginner, the best hydrofoil for you is undoubtedly the aluminum one. Not only for the price but also because it is actually the best choice in terms of features because aluminum foils are generally more stable and easier to use.